Honeymoon Beach VS Trunk Bay: Compare 2 of the best

Honeymoon Beach water island vs Trunk Bay St John

Are you ready for the best beach guide? If so, let’s dive deep into the tropical beauty of Honeymoon Beach and Trunk Bay. Then hoist the anchor and set sail on this adventure to help you decide. Which is surely best for you, Honeymoon Beach or Trunk Bay?

Overview Honeymoon Beach Water Island vs Trunk Bay St John

  • Where: Honeymoon Beach is on Water Island, while Trunk Bay is on St. John.
  • Vibes: Trunk Bay is postcard-perfect, and Honeymoon Beach offers an especially cozy feel.

Honeymoon Beach Water Island USVI

Honeymoon Beach is surely a secret slice of Eden on Water Island. It is a quiet spot, thus best for couples or guests who want a break from the crowds.

Honeymoon Beach Water Island

Where is Honeymoon Beach?

The beach is on Water Island, thus only a short ferry ride from St. Thomas.

Ease of Access

  • Cruise Port: No direct port, but the closest is St. Thomas cruise port
  • Airport: Cyril E. King Airport, St. Thomas
  • Rental Car or Taxi: Grab one from St. Thomas none on the island
  • Water Taxi: quick ride from St. Thomas

Best Time To Visit Honeymoon Beach

  • Winter: Both sunny and popular, so it’s pricey.
  • Spring: Still sunny, less packed.
  • Summer: Hot, also humid.
  • Fall: Quiet, but some rain.
  • Peak Season during Dec.–Apr is cooler.
  • Off-season during May–Nov deals can be found.
  • Shoulder Season: May & Nov.
  • Rainy Season: Sept.–Nov but beware of Hurricanes.

Beach Conditions and Crowds

BeachConditionsCrowdsReasons To Visit
HoneymoonSoft SandMid RangePrivacy

Top 5 Amenities List

  • Beach Chairs
  • Beach Bar
  • Kayaks
  • Snorkel Rentals
  • Floating Platforms

List of 5 Nearby Hotel Options

  • Emerald Beach Resort: Close to the airport.
  • Bolongo Bay Beach Resort: All-inclusive options.
  • Frenchman’s Reef: Luxury amenities.
  • Island Beachcomber Hotel: Budget-friendly.
  • Mafolie Hotel: Striking views.

List of 5 Nearby Food Options

  • Heidi’s Honeymoon Grill: Quick bites.
  • Dinghy’s Beach Bar and Grill: Ideal drinks.
  • The Pie Whole: Pizza and more.
  • Barefoot Buddha: Breakfast and coffee.
  • Havana Blue: Deluxe dining.

History and Culture

  • History: Originally private land, but now open to the public.
  • Culture: casual and calm, the ideal of island life.

Table of Nearby Things To Do Honeymoon Beach:

ActivityCrowdsReasons To Visit
Water Island Bike TourLowScenic island quest
St. Thomas SkyrideHILovely views
Coral World Ocean ParkMidMarine Park St Thomas

Is Honeymoon Beach Safe?

  • Beach Patrols are not always present; thus, be aware.
  • It has some rocky areas, so wear reef shoes.
  • Always still keep an eye on your gear.

Top 5 Pros Honeymoon Beach

  • Less Crowded
  • Private Feel
  • Ideal Snorkeling
  • Family-Friendly
  • Mix of  Activities

Top 5 Cons Honeymoon Beach

  • No Direct Cruise Port
  • Smaller Beach Area
  • Limited Amenities
  • No Lifeguard
  • easy to access from the cruise port

Is Honeymoon Beach worth it?

It is, especially if you’re into secret spots and cozy vibes.

  • Who: Couples, families, and solo travelers
  • What: A laid-back beach with natural beauty
  • Why: It is less crowded but offers various activities
  • When: Peak season for less rain, off-season for less crowd
  • Where: Water Island, so a short trip from St. Thomas
  • How: Via ferry, taxi, or water taxi
  • How Much: Free to visit however, you pay for amenities and transport.

How long should I stay at Honeymoon Beach

A day or two is perfect, so soak up what Honeymoon Beach offers.

Click here to see if St Thomas Still Worth Seeing-Unlock 10 0f The Best Reasons Why


Trunk Bay Saint John USVI

Welcome to Trunk Bay, surely the crown jewel of St. John. It’s the ideal beach destination, famed for both its snorkeling trail and powdery white sand.

Where is Trunk Bay?

Trunk Bay St John

Trunk Bay is located on the island of St. John in the U.S. Virgin Islands.

Ease of Access

  • Cruise Port: No direct port, but the closest is St. Thomas
  • Airport: Cyril E. King Airport, St. Thomas
  • Rental Car or Taxi: From St. Thomas or within St. John
  • Water Taxi: Available from St. Thomas

Best Time To Visit Trunk Bay

  • Winter: Ideal conditions but crowded.
  • Spring: Pleasant weather, but still has fewer people.
  • Summer: Hot, humid, but colorful marine life.
  • Fall: Off-season, possible rain, yet still enjoyable.
  • Peak Season: Dec.–Apr..
  • Off-Season: May–Nov..
  • Shoulder Season: May & Nov..
  • Rainy Season: Sept.–Nov but beware of Hurricanes.

Beach Conditions and Crowds

BeachConditionsCrowdsReasons To Visit
Trunk BaySoft SandHighSnorkeling

Click Here: Magens Bay compared to Trunk Bay: How To Make The Best Choice

Top 5 Amenities List

  • Snorkeling Gear
  • Beach Chairs
  • Food Stalls
  • Parking Lot
  • Showers

List of 5 Nearby Hotel Options

  • Caneel Bay Resort: Luxury meets nature.
  • Gallows Point Resort: Ideal for couples.
  • Westin St. John Resort: Family-friendly.
  • Concordia Eco-Resort: Eco-conscious travelers.
  • Cruz Bay Boutique Hotel: Budget-friendly.

List of 5 Nearby Food Options

  • The Longboard: Coastal cuisine.
  • Cruz Bay Landing: American & Caribbean mix.
  • Rhumb Lines: fusion.
  • Extra Virgin Bistro: Fine dining.
  • Ocean 362: Views and food both!

History and Culture

  • History: Once private land, gifted to the National Park Service.
  • Culture: Outdoorsy and adventurous, thus encapsulating the best of St. John.

Table of Nearby Things To Do Trunk Bay:

ActivityCrowdsReasons To Visit
Snorkeling TrailHIUnique marine experience
Annaberg PlantationMidHistorical insight
Ram Head TrailLowHiking with views

Is Trunk Bay Safe?

  • Beach Patrols are often present.
  • Well-marked snorkeling trail.
  • Always still maintain vigilance for your gear.

Top 5 Pros Trunk Bay

  • Crystal Clear Waters
  • Well-Maintained
  •  Snorkeling Trail
  • Amenities Available
  • Beach Patrols Present

Top 5 Cons Trunk Bay

  • Crowded
  • Expensive
  • Limited Parking
  • Ease of Access
  • No Direct Cruise Port

Is Trunk Bay worth it

Yes. It’s a must-visit, especially for first-timers to the US Virgin Islands.

  • Who: Families, couples, and solo travelers
  • What: A scenic beach with excellent snorkeling
  • Why: Clear waters, snorkeling trail, and amenities
  • When: Peak season for best conditions, off-season for solitude
  • Where: St. John, a ferry ride from St. Thomas
  • How: Via ferry, taxi, or water taxi
  • How Much: $5 entry fee, also any amenity costs

How long should I stay at Trunk Bay

You’d want to spend at least a full day to enjoy Trunk Bay to the fullest.

Is Magens Bay Safe? How To Make The Best Of It

Final thoughts

Key Takeaway Table:

Honeymoon BeachTrunk Bay
Ideal forCouplesFamilies
Best Time to VisitDec.-Apr.Dec.-Apr.
AmenitiesFewExtensive
Ease of AccessModerateHI
CostMidHI

Which Is Better for You, Honeymoon Beach or Trunk Bay St John?

The answer surely depends on what you’re looking for in a beach escape. So, let’s break down Honeymoon Beach VS Trunk Bay:

Honeymoon Beach: The Cozy Choice 🌴

  • Ideal For Couples and also privacy seekers.
  • Vibe surely more laid-back, less touristy.
  • Pros: Less crowded, thus excellent for snorkeling, and has a more private feel.
  • Cons: Smaller beach area, also limited amenities, no direct cruise port.

Trunk Bay: The Iconic Option 🏖️

  • Ideal For: Families, first-time visitors
  • Vibe: Buzzing, more tourist-oriented
  • Pros: Clear waters, underwater snorkeling trail, lifeguards often present
  • Cons: Crowded, more expensive, limited parking

Read more about St John here.

What do you think so far, Honeymoon Beach or Trunk Bay St John?

  • Honeymoon Beach is for you if you want a relaxed, once off-the-beaten-path. It’s got that secret paradise aura about it.
  • On the other hand, Trunk Bay is the go-to for people seeking a more structured beach feel, full of amenities and a marked snorkeling trail.

So there you have it, the best guide for Honeymoon Beach vs. Trunk Bay. Once you pick, dive in, kick back, and live the island life to the fullest. Ready, set, beach! 🌊🍹

So, what are some of your own best traveling hacks? Then share them with us below!

Hi I am Curtis for GoateEscapes.com, I specialize in beach vacations and tropical destinations, particularly in the Caribbean. My extensive experience in the logistics of tourism and travel industry. Born in the Caribbean: I have a personal connection and deep understanding of the Caribbean people places & things. Over 20 Years in Tourism organizing sports events, corporate retreats, concerts, and working with both boutique and major hotels. I love escapes and inspiring you to embark on your own greatest of all times escapes.