St Croix Vs St Thomas: Is It Better To Be Less Or More Vibrant

Ah, the Caribbean! In summary an Eden where the sun kisses your skin. While the ocean sings you to sleep. Undeniably two stars in this sea are St. Croix and St. Thomas. But the big quiz: St Croix or St Thomas for your perfect escape? So let’s break it down quickly, point by point. To help you make the best decision.

Eager for more Island dreams? Check out how to make the best Grand Cayman vs. Turks and Caicos day.

I. Location and Geography St Croix vs. St Thomas

What is special about St. Croix?

• Being that it is the Largest of the U.S. Virgin Islands so more organic feel
• So it has a mix of rainforests and hills
• Less touristy but still accessible

What is special about St. Thomas?

• Small but has ease of access to 40 vibrant beaches
• Winding Hills and also lovely vistas
• While Buzzing with tourism and shopping
• St Thomas 5 Day Itinerary: A Journey Through Paradise

Quick Geography Comparison

Before you decide, unlock the best reasons to visit St. Thomas here.

II. History and Culture St Croix Vs St Thomas

St. Croix

• Rich in Danish and also a African past
• Plantation History

St. Thomas

• Busy Cruise Port history
• A blend of U.S. and Euro Caribbean influences

Get cultured! Know when to catch the vibe by visiting during the best times.

III. Attractions and Activities St Croix vs. St Thomas

In St. Croix:

• Buck Island for snorkeling
• Cruzan Rum Distillery
• Fort Christiansvaern

In St. Thomas:

• Magens Bay
• SkyRide to Paradise Point
• Duty-free shopping

Top Activities:

• Water Sports
• Hiking
• Shopping (For the shopper in you, St. Thomas is your haven)

IV. Beaches St Croix vs. St Thomas

St. Croix:

• Cane Bay
• Sandy Point

St. Thomas:

• Coki Beach
• Sapphire Beach

Whether in St. Thomas or St. Croix, your beach day can be epic.

V. Accommodations and Dining St Croix vs. St Thomas

In St. Croix, you’ll find cozy B&Bs. But St. Thomas, it’s a luxury resort bonanza. Both have an array of culinary charm and local seafood.

Top Resorts:

• St. Croix: The Buccaneer
• St. Thomas: Marriott’s Frenchman’s Cove

However for a deep dive into resorts, check here.

VI. Nightlife and Entertainment St Croix vs. St Thomas

St. Croix:

• Quiet, friendly bars

St. Thomas:

• Thriving clubs and live music

Still want more on St. Thomas nightlife, head here.

VII. Accessibility and Transportation

St Thomas is the easiest Virgin Island to visit. Getting to St. Croix can be trickier than St. Thomas. However, once you’re there, both islands offer taxis, car rentals, and ferries.

Want to island-hop to Water Island? Then Learn how to do it smoothly.

VIII. Cost of Travel St Croix vs. St Thomas

St. Croix:

• Generally cheaper

St. Thomas:

• It can be pricier, especially during the peak season.

Are you looking to save during your trip? Then click here for the worst and best times to visit.

IX. Pros and Cons St Croix vs. St Thomas

St. Croix Pros

• Less touristy
• Rich history

St. Thomas Pros

• More amenities
• Easy access

Both Islands’ Cons

• Can be costly

So do you want to know how long to stay? Click here.

X. Conclusion

Finally, which island is better St. Croix or St. Thomas. St Croix is when you want a calm retreat. But St Thomas for a bustling vibe. All in All, the choice boils down to what you desire. So make your pick. Regardless, paradise awaits!

Before you go, check out St. Croix and St. Thomas tourism sites.

XI. Additional Resources

• St. Croix Tourism
• St. Thomas Tourism
• GoatEscapes Ultimate Caribbean Guide

Key Takeaways Table: How does St Croix compare to St Thomas?

That’s a wrap! For more GOAT escapes, keep cruising with GoatEscapes.

So what are some of your own best traveling hacks? Share them with us below!